According to Genesis, God breathed into the first human “the breath of life (נשׁמת חיים; nishmat hayyim)” (2:7). This God-given “breath” (נשׁמה; neshamah) is the means by which humans receive their animating “spirit” (רוח; ruach). While the human body will, one day, return to dust (e.g., Gen 3:19; Job 34:15; Ps 104:29), “the spirit (רוח; ruach) returns to God who gave it” (Ecc 12:7). On the one hand, though we live in a physical world, our internal spirit is ethereal – that is, not strictly physical. On the other hand, with respect to that which is beyond the earthly realm, the Bible describes spirit-beings—while not made of flesh and blood—as corporeal entities with spatial and, sometimes, visible bodies.

Israel’s Scriptures offer a glimpse into the embodied spiritual realm in the story of Saul and the medium at En-dor (1 Samuel 28). After the prophet Samuel dies, the Philistines encamp against the Israelites. Saul asks God whether he should engage in battle, “but the Lord did not answer him” (1 Sam 28:6). In response to this divine silence, Saul finds a medium in En-dor and asks her, “Divine for me by means of a spirit (באוב; ba’ov) and… bring up Samuel for me” (28:8, 11). When the medium does so, Saul asks, “‘What is his appearance?’ And she said, ‘An old man is coming up, and he is wrapped in a robe.’ And Saul knew that it was Samuel” (28:14). Saul knows that the “old man” (אישׁ זקן; ‘ish zaqen) who emerges from the afterlife is Samuel because the prophet is wearing the “robe” (מעיל; me’il) that his mother Hannah had made for him each year as he grew up (see 1 Sam 2:19). While Samuel’s earthly body has been buried in his hometown of Ramah (see 1 Sam 28:3), and he now “comes up” (עלה; ‘oleh) from the non-physical realm of the dead, he is still very much embodied when he meets Saul at En-dor.

This view of an embodied Samuel in the spirit realm coheres with Job’s description of spirits. Eliphaz tells his suffering friend of a spiritual experience that he once had during “visions of the night” (Job 4:13). He recalls to Job, “A spirit (רוח; ruach) glided past my face; the hair of my skin stood up. [The spirit] stood still, but I could not discern its appearance, [though] a form was before my eyes” (4:15-16). While Eliphaz cannot make out the “appearance” (מראה; mareh) of the spirit, it nevertheless possesses an embodied “form” (תמינה; temunah) that both moves (going past Eliphaz’s face) and “stands” (עמד; amad) in physical space. The biblical language emphasizes the fact that the “spirit” (רוח; ruach) that Eliphaz encounters has a body.

The embodiment of spirits also appears in the New Testament. For instance, when Jesus is baptized, “the Holy Spirit descended, like a dove, in bodily form (σωματικῷ εἴδει; somatiko eidei)” (Lk 3:22). Thus, when Jesus says in John 4:24 that “God is Spirit” (πνεῦμα ὁ θεός; pneuma ho theós) this does not preclude the notion—repeated throughout the Bible—that God has a bodily form (e.g., Exod 24:9-10; 33:20-23; Num 12:8). In biblical thought, while the spiritual realm is not one of “flesh and blood” (cf. 1 Cor 15:50), a spirit can, indeed, have a body.

BEGIN YOUR JOURNEY OF DISCOVERY

46 COMMENTS

  1. Shalom; a very interesting read, which reminds me of the amazing story of the prophecy to his parents of the birth of Samson; this heavenly Visitor just chats away to them like another earthling and then ascends to heaven in the flames of their burnt offering! Wow!
    Judges 13.

    • Shalom, that was an out-of-this-world scenario. Manoah and his wife thought they were surely going to die. Yahweh’s servants are truly awesome as is their Lord, who is forever praised.

  2. Jesus’ statement as he ate a piece of honeycomb before his disciples, urging them to touch Him to see that he was not a mere spirit, gives incite into the nature of a spirit in a visible form, “A spirit does not have flesh and bones”. Angels ate Abram’s food!

  3. I am of the opinion that when ever a spirit makes contact with the living it is demonic . The Story Jesus graphically describes of the rich man and Lazurus is to my understanding complete description that those that are there cannot come to those that are here .

    • Thanks for your input, Howard. I would be cautious about import the term “demonic” into the discussion, since nowhere does the biblical text use this term with reference to spirit encounters. More, Samuel’s appearance to Saul wasn’t “demonic” (that is, Samuel is not a “demon” in the afterlife).

    • Israel Bible Center equips you with the tools you need to enter into the Jewish world of Scripture. We provide first-rate teaching, and the opportunity to learn from some of the world’s top scholars. As a student, you will be able to interact personally with our teaching faculty, and gain access to hundreds of hours of Bible courses, including The Jewish Gospel of Matthew and The Hebrew Psalms: How To Worship God. Become a part of the community of teachers and students at Israel Bible Center today!

      • It is true “Samuel is not a “demon” in the afterlife.” However a demon can impersonate the dead, and may do so in corporeal form. I agree with Mr. Lucas that whenever we hear from the dead it is highly likely we are in fact dealing with demonic forces. The fact Saul had to go to a witch is evidence enough in this case.

        Obviously when Yeshua or the prophets of The Most High brought someone back from the dead this was not the case, so we probably shouldn’t make a blanket statement either way. But if I saw a dead person, even if it were my own parents I think I’d be doing some powerful prayin’ right about then!

        • I as well do not believe it was Samuel but a demon that Saul thought was Samuel. God says have nothing to do with witches and those who ‘conversed with the dead’ and would not have used one to answer Saul.

          • Please re-read the story, especially 1 Samuel 28:13-21. From that account, the following facts prevail. 1. The woman is shocked and afraid at what she sees implying that is was not of her typical realm of mediation. 2. The being is called ‘Divine’ not Demonic. 3. The divine being has the ability to prophesy the future and tells Saul he will be dead by the next day. 4. The divine being told Saul God has become his adversary. 5. The divine being told Saul he was Samuel and that in life he had warned him. Therefore how can you contradict the story with your views? Demonic beings have no ability to see the future. Demonic beings do not report on who God has abandoned, nor would demonic beings be cantancerous about being disturbed about being raised out of the Fires of Hell. The Demons in all bible stories are always trying to escape Hell! They have limited knowledge of God and if anything would have offered Saul a way of escape in exchange for his soul.

    • Apparently then the Holy Bible is s a big lie!! The 2 angels that appeared to Lot in Sodom. The angels that appeared to Abraham. The angel that wrestled with a disciple. God appearing as a dove at the baptism of Jesus—

  4. Thanks for letting me know about this message on spirit’s because I lost my sister Karen in April and I believe that I see her spirit even though I know it’s here or my mom or Dad or my Husband’s children’s mother I’m not Afraid I know they are okay

  5. I disagree that a spirit has a body .
    After the resurrection of Jesus he showed them his hands as proof that he was not a spirit he said so himself ,for a spirit has no flesh and bone as you see me have

    • Howard, note that the article says twice that spirit-bodies are not made of “flesh and blood.” Spirits have bodies, but the aren’t made of the same material as human bodies, which is exactly what Lk 24:39 is saying.

    • Israel Bible Center equips you with the tools you need to enter into the Jewish world of Scripture. We provide first-rate teaching, and the opportunity to learn from some of the world’s top scholars. As a student, you will be able to interact personally with our teaching faculty, and gain access to hundreds of hours of Bible courses, including The Jewish Gospel of Matthew and The Hebrew Psalms: How To Worship God. Become a part of the community of teachers and students at Israel Bible Center today!

      • Amen! The spirits have to have a form, not just some floating cloud that is ever-changing, but one that the LORD of Hosts has given it to be. Thus He is the only Spirit whose nature is self-perpetuating.

    • Where is it written that Jesus resurrected in Spirit?? In Greek resurrection ”ANASTASIS” literally means to PHYSICAL resurrection of the BODY. There is another word in Greek for resurrection if not bodily.

      • Read John 20:11-18 Mary Magdalene sees the risen Lord NKJV

        I believe he was still in the spirit, that is why Yeshua told Mary Magdalene, “Do not cling to Me, for I have not yet ascended to My Father”…..

  6. my ignorance – When the spirit (ruach) returns to God at death and the body returns to the earth – is there still a soul? and when, a sinner are thrown in the lake of fire – what living being is he/her without the ruach of God. exciting to know

  7. Jesus was not raised a spirit being(as a Jehovah’s Witnesses teach after Resurrection), but was raised in his resurrected body.

  8. I understood that Jesus was in His resurrection body when He spent time with his disciples. We, too, are promised new bodies, resurrection bodies like His, which I assume to be solid bodies that can eat and hug, but are also spiritual bodies.

  9. What people “see and hear” in the situation and context described and their consequent descriptive statements is not evidence that “a spirit” is corporeal. People see star formations as Gods, animals. People hear voices in the wind.

    • Winston, not only does Eliphaz “see and hear” the spirit in Job, but the spirit “stands” nexts to him — one needs to be corporeal in order to stand. More, Luke notes that the Holy Spirit descended in “bodily form” at Jesus’ baptism. The Gospel writer doesn’t present this event merely as the audiences’ (false) perception, but rather an accurate description of the Spirit’s embodiment.

    • We are very happy that you’ve joined our discussion forum. Would you believe that these articles are only a taste of what Israel Bible Center has to offer? We also provide comprehensive teaching on a variety of biblical, historical, and cultural topics. You might begin with The Jewish Gospel of Matthew or The Hebrew Psalms: How To Worship God. You’ll be amazed at the Jewish world that awaits you. Don’t delay another minute: enroll now!

      • Why did Jesus get baptised? John’s baptism was a baptism of repentance from sin afterall. Why did the Holy Spirit come upon Him? He is God incarnate. Jesus is the Word of God… and yet a voice, discernible in time and space, the words of God, came from Heaven. In each of these things was a profound expression of God identifying the uniqueness of Christ, being one of us. Again profoundly pregnant with meaning and very fulfilling of expectations of the people of the time. Kind of shoots down the greek thought of Jesus having two natures – human and divine. For how could Jesus redeem us if he was anything other than a perfect human. He is God incarnate, the Word become flesh, but if He was a two-natured being He would be super or sub human and His death would not have benefit us as He would be other than us.

  10. I believe that the body is the soul and the the spirit is the breath of life, and that our spirit of life leaves our body at death As God said that the living know that they shall die,but the dead know not anything .

  11. Galatians 5.17 For the flesh lusteth against the Spirit, and the Spirit against the flesh: and these are contrary the one to the other….
    I don’t know how english speaking understand this verse but in the original Koini Greek language the meaning is more than clear leaving no doubts or…

  12. I find this topic intriguing. Much, of every religion, is based in the belief of the immortal soul and/or spirit. It is my observation that the Genesis account of man’s creation seems to indicate that clay plus God’s spark of life is the make up of the man.

  13. To many disagreements over scripture topics end poorly. If we can be innocent as little children then greater mysteries may be revealed. Satan’s first lie involved life and death. Did Satan say we would not really die? Was Satan promoting the concept of the immortal human soul.

  14. The resurrected body of our Lord Jesus is a “supernatural” one. It is different in some ways than our earthly bodies. We will have the same as promised in the rapture.

  15. This is definitely a tangent, but C.S. Lewis’ space trilogy posits “spirit beings” (eldila) that are embodies only in the sense that their bodies and voices have an effect on our material world but it is a different effect that we have on the world. It’s a very intriguing concept.

  16. I’m not 100% clear on this, but I’ll put it out there anyhow:

    In the case of God, He has manifest Himself in physical form many times and many ways; the most notable being Yeshua. But I’d think the ability to manifest as a corporeal being is a much different thing than “having” a physical body. Saying God has a body sounds like an Apocryphal tradition rather than scriptural exegesis.

    Good, thought provoking artical regardless. ‘Preciate it!

    • Good thoughts, Daniel. I appreciate your input. One reason to refer to God “having a body,” as opposed to merely “manifesting” in corporeal form on earth, is that God is described as embodied while in heaven (e.g., Isa 66:1; Ps 104:3; Dan 7:9-10). God’s embodiment sounds apocryphal because both Jewish and Christian tradition has assumed God’s incorporeality (and taught that God has no body) without giving enough attention to what the biblical texts actually say.

    • Israel Bible Center equips you with the tools you need to enter into the Jewish world of Scripture. We provide first-rate teaching, and the opportunity to learn from some of the world’s top scholars. As a student, you will be able to interact personally with our teaching faculty, and gain access to hundreds of hours of Bible courses, including The Jewish Gospel of Matthew and The Hebrew Psalms: How To Worship God. Become a part of the community of teachers and students at Israel Bible Center today!

      • Perhaps the reason that God is referred to as having a body, sitting on a throne, or when Moses saw the back of God, is more to do with human appreciation and comprehension needs rather than who He is. Why would God have a body for us to see if He is omnipresent even beyond creation? To even refer to God as being omnipresent is limiting to the truth of who God is as omnipresent means time and space. He transcends time and space. The manifestation of Elijah and Moses with Jesus at the Transfiguration was a deliberate and calculated, but profound, statement to the realms of creation of who Jesus is. It is pregnant with meaning. Hebrew writings, though insightful are still finite in their comprehension of the works, ways and being that is the I AM.

  17. Interesting. I know that God appeared to Abraham and Moses in some form. There is much we will not know for certain in this lifetime. I trust that God will take me to Heaven in some form when I die. God did not say we could not conjure up Spirits but I think He said we should not.

  18. The life that is God breathed would be simpler to understand as a living creations’ life-force. All living things have a God-breathed life force. When any living thing eventually dies, the life is exhaled, extinguished, going back to God as it were. Man also has a life force, but is unique from all other living things as man is created in His image. He has an aspect of himself that is sovereign, perceptive, intelligent, comprehending, able to originate thought. Look how much attention is written about the uniqueness of man as opposed to all other living things. Look how we are to repent but are the animals? The flowers, the trees? Never confuse the attributes of the human body which is mammalian with its purpose… to house a sovereign entity made in the Creators image. You cannot split the body from the life force, nor either two from that eternal spirit-entity (God’s image) that a human is. The body turns to dust. The life-force expires. The living spiritual entity that we all are will be raised – for eternal joy with the Majesty on High, or not.

  19. Why do you change the sequence of words? Luke says: The Holy Spirit descending in bodily form (=appearance; he didn’t use ‘morphè’) like a dove. But you turn it into: The Holy Spirit descending, like a dove, in bodily form. Why?

    • It’s not a matter of changing the word sequence. The syntax reads, “The Holy Spirit descending in bodily form, like a dove.” That is, the Spirit descends in bodily form, just as a dove might descend in bodily form, but Luke is not making a comment on what the Spirit’s body looks like.

    • Israel Bible Center equips you with the tools you need to enter into the Jewish world of Scripture. We provide first-rate teaching, and the opportunity to learn from some of the world’s top scholars. As a student, you will be able to interact personally with our teaching faculty, and gain access to hundreds of hours of Bible courses, including The Jewish Gospel of Matthew and The Hebrew Psalms: How To Worship God. Become a part of the community of teachers and students at Israel Bible Center today!

  20. Please explain how a spirit wich is neither flesh or blood can have a nstural or fleshly body because when Moses spoke to God and ssked for His fsce God which is Spirit said no man can see me and live

    • Spirits do not have bodies made of flesh, but they have bodies of some kind. While Moses doesn’t see God’s face when he asks to see it (in Exodus 33), he does see God’s face at other times (e.g., Numbers 12:8).

  21. The major question here if whether God himself has a body,? since spirits have spiritual body. It is generally believed that when Jesus told the woman at the well that God is spirit, then it means God has no body since he is everywhere.

  22. This was a very interesting reading. I too believe that the Spirit can have a body form. After The Resurrection, JESUS came to the Desciples; the doors being locked and stood before them. This is proof that JESUS was in a body that they could see, yet HE was SPIRIT.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your name here
Words left: 50
Please enter your comment!