Is there any difference between the words “gift” and “government”? How about “management” and “trust”? “Work” and “plan”? “Commission” and “dispensation”? “Position” and “obligation”? Believe it or not, all of these very different words are used in well-known Bible translations as equivalents for a single Jewish-Greek word: οἰκονομία (oikonomia).
The Greek oikonomia is the origin of our word “economy.” In ancient Hellas, it meant “household management,” that is, the administration of the affairs, possessions, and servants of a family unit. This noun appears twice in the Jewish-Greek Septuagint translation of the Hebrew Bible (Isa 22:19, 22:21). The related verb, οἰκονομέω (oikonomeō) “to manage a household,” appears once:
Good is the man who pities and lends:
he shall manage (oikonomeō) his affairs with judgment. (Ps 111/112:5)
This couplet is a clear instance of “parallelism” in Hebrew poetry. The second line develops the meaning of the first line, explaining that a person who lends money out of compassion for a neighbor – as the Hebrew Torah commands – is in fact “managing a household” justly and well.
The word oikonomia also appears several times in the first-century Jewish messianic writings known to Christians as the “New Testament” (Lk 16:2-4; 1 Cor 9:17; Eph 1:10, 3:2, 3:9; Col 1:25; 1 Tim 1:4). Probably the most common English translation is “stewardship,” which is not a bad option. However, English versions are very inconsistent in translating the term, using all of the words listed at the beginning of this essay and many more as well! This means that most readers have no idea that the original Jewish-Greek texts use the same word in all these places. In addition, readers may receive a very misleading impression of some passages.
Some English versions use the word “dispensation” in a few places to translate oikonomia. Like any word, this one can have various meanings. When isolated from other passages that use the word oikonomia and divorced from the original contexts, phrases like “the dispensation of the grace” (Eph 3:2) and “the dispensation of the mystery” (3:9) sound like they are talking about something obscure, theological, and non-Jewish – certainly not something as mundane as “household management.” In fact, entire theological systems (like “dispensationalism”) have been built up around such words. Very often those religious systems of thought – together with the inconsistent translations – orient people in an extremely anti-Jewish direction. The only solution is to study the language, literature, and culture of the first-century Jewish world in order to understand these texts in their original settings.
Shalom! Deixe-me ver se interpretei bem o texto; Devemos, no plano da graça, conduzir nossa vida com justiça? Se me falta..por favor ajude-me a entender melhor. Não que o texto esteja complicado.Não. Pelo contrário, está graciosamente bem explicado. Só nesse ponto da dispensação (Ef 3.2). Acertei? Obrigado. Thank you for the comment, Maria. In Eph 3:2 the Jewish writer Shaul/Paul is explaining why he addresses Gentiles (non-Jews). He says he has been entrusted with this particular area of "household management" or "stewardship." Later theological writers took this phrase out of context and used it as a foundation for an entire theory of interpretation and worldview. Shalom!
Is the Lxx Jewish-Greek or the translation of the TaNaK in Greek done around 250BCE by Greek speaking Jews for the sake of the Hellenic speaking Jews who lived in Alexandria Egypt? Why call it Jewish-Greek? Are you not stretching this academic point hitch as a tremendous blessing to the use of the scripture to non-Jewish peoples? So in Ephesians 3:2 should we say economy of Grace rather than dispensation of grace and in 3:9 economy of the mystery? You should know Dr Eli that we use the best idiom and sense to translate from one language. Thanks for the comment/questions, Amos. You raise large issues that are dealt with in more detail in our courses and in multiple articles on this site. I'll try to give some brief answers here: [cont.] Héritière de ma famille, je parle judéo-persan. Pour toi, y-at-il honte ? Avant de juger, apprends. Shalom
I have continually disagreements with people. "But this word doesn't mean "this", it means "that", and I tell them "a word means what it originally meant. People changes their meanings. Words; never". Thank you for the comment, Lars-Toralf! But how do you deal with the historical evidence that words do change their meanings over time (and space)?
I agree completely that the writings of a first century Jewish religious sect ought to be studied within that context. I'd add it also ought to be studied within the context of first century Roman culture and religion. This is especially true of writings intended for Gentile audiences. Thank you, John! Yes, the entire historical, linguistic, social, political, etc. context has to be taken into account. For these texts, that generally means consideration of the Greco-Roman-Jewish setting. :) You may be interested in this interview with Dr. Steve Mason which addresses relevant questions of context and reading: We are very happy that you’ve joined our discussion forum. Would you believe that these articles are only a taste of what Israel Bible Center has to offer? We also provide comprehensive teaching on a variety of biblical, historical, and cultural topics. You might begin with The Name of God or Exploring Jewish Interpretation. You’ll be amazed at the Jewish world that awaits you. Don’t delay another minute: enroll now!
Shalom, I propose a suitable way to consider translation is ultimately based on fundamentals of communication: The end goal is to produce a similar picture in the mind of the listener that is in the mind of the speaker. This picture reproduction will need to overcome existing baggage everyone collects. Really, I'm spiking! Very, very happy. God is Blazing in your society! Thank you, Augustin! Great to have you as part of our learning collective. Israel Bible Center equips you with the tools you need to enter into the Jewish world of Scripture. We provide first-rate teaching, and the opportunity to learn from some of the world’s top scholars. As a student, you will be able to interact personally with our teaching faculty, and gain access to hundreds of hours of Bible courses, including The Name of God and Exploring Jewish Interpretation. Become a part of the community of teachers and students at Israel Bible Center today!
Could you imagine 1 Kings 3:16 an allegory? The southern kingdom, accidentally killing her Moshiach, and the northern receiving her king in Ezekiel-37? Could the child's feet have had a sword between them? Inverted? Zayin between two gimels? Prophetically pointing to Mathew 19:12 indicating Mathew 19:28? A faithful Priest- 1Sam.2:35? I haven't garnered the strength to discuss my damaged seed without the Matthew 19:12 spring-board untill recently; I have to confess it is a Matthew 5:30 condition. Perhaps this alludes to the being "raised up"(1Sam.2:35) or "despised the day of small things"(Zech.4:10) aspects of my description. Even a "twig"(Isaiah.11:1.JPS)...brutal. Isaiah.40:31
Hi Dr. Gruber. Just in brief, what is dispensationalism? Hi Thandu,
Wow! It's amazing to think that home, economy, stewardship and (one of the most important of Jesus' teaching) parable of talents, would be linked to the Shema's mo'ev - to love your God with all we have (resources). ... it's takes the Old Root origin to straighten out the wayward Vines ... how language can lead astray ... & create outliers of belief that are far removed from the Old Root of Israel ; from the original context... to stay true to form, is to be intimate with Hebrew Israel origins ... this is beyond a doubt ... a 'mind alignment' is necessary to straighten out the path to liberty in & through immersion in the righteousness of the Word .... not wrongteousness of superficial opinion put forth by those of no healthy Intellectual Humility ... to get it right (write), is to get it Real ...
Load more commentsLXX = Jewish Greek or the Greek translation of the Hebrew Bible? Both.
Why call it Jewish Greek? These Greek texts written by Jews have special characteristics that distinguish them from other Greek texts. Hence, "Jewish Greek" -- a term that is straightforward, easily understandable, and commonly used by scholars in the field.
Stretching a hitch? I'm not sure what you mean here.
...
Always translate oikonomia as "economy"? Not in my opinion. However, it is very important to understand the meaning of the term in context, recognize the various places where it appears (something that is often obscured in translation), and avoid decontextualized theologizations! These are the points made in the article.
Best idiom? Well, there are many different approaches to translation. All of them have advantages and disadvantages. Every single translation choice will have pros and cons. However, the point is that many of these inconsistent translations actually distort the original.
Dr. Eli? Here is his take:
https://weekly.israelbiblecenter.com/the-original-language-of-new-testament/
+ More answers (1)
https://israelbiblecenter.com/roundtable-talks/josephus-roman-judaea/
+ More answers (1)
Dispensationalism is a specific Christian theological framework or system that arose in the 19th century. Its main idea (as I understand it) is that history is divided into particular periods (called "dispensations") during which God had particular ways of relating to humans. Dispensationalism implies that God's way of relating was different in each period.
You could start with general reference materials:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dispensationalism
+ More answers (1)